Hawaii Probate Types: Informal vs Formal
Hawaii sorts its routes by how much of the estate is in dispute and who runs it, not by price. Every court route opens for the same $215, and the only charge that grows with the estate belongs to the clerk-run small estate.
Compare eligibility, timing, court involvement, and local verification points
How to Compare Hawaii Probate Types
One kind of court hears all of it. Probate in Hawaii belongs to the circuit courts (HRS § 603-21.6), and a case is filed in the circuit court of the judicial circuit where the decedent was domiciled at death (§ 560:3-201(a)(1)). There are four circuits: the First (Oahu), the Second (Maui, Molokai and Lanai, including Kalawao), the Third (Hawaii Island) and the Fifth (Kauai and Niihau). No county runs a probate court of its own.
The six routes fall into three groups. Three are court administrations that differ in who decides and how closely: informal probate goes to the REGISTRAR without a hearing, formal testacy is litigation before a judge on notice, and supervised administration keeps the whole estate under the court's continuing authority until discharge. Two are small-estate shortcuts that still run through the court: the clerk of the circuit court can administer an estate of property in Hawaii of a total value not exceeding $100,000 (§ 560:3-1205), and the § 560:3-1203 summary procedure lets an appointed personal representative distribute without creditor notice where the allowances and expenses would take the whole estate. The last one never reaches a court: the § 560:3-1201 affidavit collects personal property when the gross value of the estate in Hawaii is $100,000 or less.
Fees do not scale with the estate. HRS § 607-5(b)(14) sets one $100 probate fee paid once for each decedent's estate, whether the case is informal, formal or ancillary, and the clerk collects $215 at filing once the $50 administrative fee of § 607-5(c)(32) and the $65 indigent legal services surcharge of § 607-5.7(a)(2) are added. The one value-based charge is the clerk's own fee in a clerk-run small estate: three per cent of the market value of the first $100,000 of the gross estate (§ 560:3-1211).
Informal vs Formal at a Glance
Scroll the table sideways to see every column. Use the arrow keys when the table is focused.
| Category | Informal | Formal | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who decides | The REGISTRAR, on a verified application, with no hearing (HRS §§ 560:3-301 and 560:1-307) | A circuit judge, on a petition, after notice and hearing (§ 560:3-401) | Tie |
| Cost to open | $215 collected at filing, once for the estate | The same $215. A jury demand adds $200 (§ 607-5(c)(21)) | Tie |
| Earliest appointment | 120 hours after the death for a priority applicant, or fourteen days after mailed notice for anyone else (§ 560:3-302) | After notice and a hearing, which takes longer | Informal |
| Creditor window | Four months from first publication, if the estate publishes; eighteen months after death if no notice is given | The same periods. § 560:3-803 does not vary with the route | Tie |
| Earliest closing | Six months after appointment, by verified statement (§ 560:3-1003(a)) | The same floor for an unsupervised estate. Choosing formal does not shorten it | Tie |
| When it is the wrong choice | When anyone is likely to challenge the will or the appointment, since a formal petition halts informal action | When everyone agrees, because it adds notice and hearings for no gain | Tie |
| Best fit | An agreed family, a will nobody challenges, and one obvious person to appoint | A contested will, competing applicants, uncertain heirs, or a family that wants a judge to rule | Tie |
Who decides
TieInformal: The REGISTRAR, on a verified application, with no hearing (HRS §§ 560:3-301 and 560:1-307)
Formal: A circuit judge, on a petition, after notice and hearing (§ 560:3-401)
Cost to open
TieInformal: $215 collected at filing, once for the estate
Formal: The same $215. A jury demand adds $200 (§ 607-5(c)(21))
Earliest appointment
InformalInformal: 120 hours after the death for a priority applicant, or fourteen days after mailed notice for anyone else (§ 560:3-302)
Formal: After notice and a hearing, which takes longer
Creditor window
TieInformal: Four months from first publication, if the estate publishes; eighteen months after death if no notice is given
Formal: The same periods. § 560:3-803 does not vary with the route
Earliest closing
TieInformal: Six months after appointment, by verified statement (§ 560:3-1003(a))
Formal: The same floor for an unsupervised estate. Choosing formal does not shorten it
When it is the wrong choice
TieInformal: When anyone is likely to challenge the will or the appointment, since a formal petition halts informal action
Formal: When everyone agrees, because it adds notice and hearings for no gain
Best fit
TieInformal: An agreed family, a will nobody challenges, and one obvious person to appoint
Formal: A contested will, competing applicants, uncertain heirs, or a family that wants a judge to rule
Main Hawaii Probate Options
Scroll the table sideways to see every column. Use the arrow keys when the table is focused.
| Probate Type | Threshold | Filing Fee | Timeline | Real Estate | Attorney | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Informal Probate and Informal Appointment HRS §§ 560:3-301 to 560:3-311, with the fee at § 607-5(b)(14) | No dollar threshold. The ordinary route where nothing is contested. | $215 collected at filing ($100 probate fee, $50 administrative fee, $65 surcharge), paid once for the estate | Appointment no sooner than 120 hours after the death (thirty days for a non-resident, with exceptions). Closing by sworn statement no sooner than six months after appointment (§ 560:3-1003(a)) | Yes | No statutory requirement. Counsel is usual once there is real estate to sell, a business to wind up or a claim in dispute | An uncontested estate that needs a personal representative, with a will nobody is challenging or an agreed family |
Formal Testacy Proceeding HRS §§ 560:3-401 to 560:3-414 | No dollar threshold. Litigation before the circuit court to decide whether the decedent left a valid will. | The same $215 collected at filing, once for the estate. A jury demand in a probate case is $200 more under § 607-5(c)(21) | Longer than informal, because each contested step is heard on notice. A will must be offered within five years of the death unless a § 560:3-108 exception applies | Yes | No statutory requirement, and rare without one. A formal proceeding is adversarial | A contested will, competing applicants for appointment, uncertain heirs, or a family that wants a judge to rule |
Supervised Administration HRS § 560:3-501 | No dollar threshold. | Governed by the same once-per-estate $100 probate fee. No separate figure is set for supervision | The longest route, because distribution waits on court approval. The six-month closing by sworn statement is not available in supervised administration | Yes | No statutory requirement, and uncommon without one | An estate where beneficiaries want the court overseeing each step, or where trust between the parties has broken down |
Clerk-Administered Small Estate HRS §§ 560:3-1205 to 560:3-1211 | Property in Hawaii of a total value not exceeding $100,000, with no personal representative appointed in Hawaii. | No ordinary court costs. Actual expenses plus three per cent of the market value of the first $100,000 of the gross estate, paid to the State, at most $3,000 (§ 560:3-1211) | The clerk distributes after sixty days for an estate of $10,000 or less and after four months above that (§ 560:3-1209) | Yes | No | A small Hawaii estate with a house or land that the affidavit cannot move, and no family member able or willing to serve |
Summary Administration HRS § 560:3-1203, closing under § 560:3-1204 | No dollar figure. The entire estate, less liens and encumbrances, must not exceed the homestead allowance, exempt property, family allowance, costs and expenses of administration, reasonable funeral expenses, and reasonable and necessary medical and hospital expenses of the last illness. | No separate fee. The estate is opened with $215 collected at filing | Shorter than an ordinary administration because it skips creditor notice, and the estate can close at any time after distribution. It cannot start until the appointment and inventory are done | Yes | No statutory requirement. The comparison against allowances and expenses is where advice pays for itself | An estate that the family allowances, the funeral bill and the last medical bills would use up once counted |
Collection of Personal Property by Affidavit HRS § 560:3-1201, effect at § 560:3-1202 | $100,000 or less, on the GROSS value of the decedent's estate in Hawaii, with nothing subtracted for liens. Hawaii real property counts toward it. Property outside Hawaii does not. | $0. It is never filed, so no fee attaches. Certified death certificates cost $10 for the first and $4 for each further copy in the same request | No statutory waiting period. Usable once a death certificate is in hand | No | No | An estate of accounts, belongings and vehicles under the line, where nobody needs to be appointed |
Informal Probate and Informal Appointment
HRS §§ 560:3-301 to 560:3-311, with the fee at § 607-5(b)(14)
An uncontested estate that needs a personal representative, with a will nobody is challenging or an agreed family
Threshold: No dollar threshold. The ordinary route where nothing is contested.
Filing Fee: $215 collected at filing ($100 probate fee, $50 administrative fee, $65 surcharge), paid once for the estate
Timeline: Appointment no sooner than 120 hours after the death (thirty days for a non-resident, with exceptions). Closing by sworn statement no sooner than six months after appointment (§ 560:3-1003(a))
Real Estate: Yes
Attorney: No statutory requirement. Counsel is usual once there is real estate to sell, a business to wind up or a claim in dispute
Formal Testacy Proceeding
HRS §§ 560:3-401 to 560:3-414
A contested will, competing applicants for appointment, uncertain heirs, or a family that wants a judge to rule
Threshold: No dollar threshold. Litigation before the circuit court to decide whether the decedent left a valid will.
Filing Fee: The same $215 collected at filing, once for the estate. A jury demand in a probate case is $200 more under § 607-5(c)(21)
Timeline: Longer than informal, because each contested step is heard on notice. A will must be offered within five years of the death unless a § 560:3-108 exception applies
Real Estate: Yes
Attorney: No statutory requirement, and rare without one. A formal proceeding is adversarial
Supervised Administration
HRS § 560:3-501
An estate where beneficiaries want the court overseeing each step, or where trust between the parties has broken down
Threshold: No dollar threshold.
Filing Fee: Governed by the same once-per-estate $100 probate fee. No separate figure is set for supervision
Timeline: The longest route, because distribution waits on court approval. The six-month closing by sworn statement is not available in supervised administration
Real Estate: Yes
Attorney: No statutory requirement, and uncommon without one
Clerk-Administered Small Estate
HRS §§ 560:3-1205 to 560:3-1211
A small Hawaii estate with a house or land that the affidavit cannot move, and no family member able or willing to serve
Threshold: Property in Hawaii of a total value not exceeding $100,000, with no personal representative appointed in Hawaii.
Filing Fee: No ordinary court costs. Actual expenses plus three per cent of the market value of the first $100,000 of the gross estate, paid to the State, at most $3,000 (§ 560:3-1211)
Timeline: The clerk distributes after sixty days for an estate of $10,000 or less and after four months above that (§ 560:3-1209)
Real Estate: Yes
Attorney: No
Summary Administration
HRS § 560:3-1203, closing under § 560:3-1204
An estate that the family allowances, the funeral bill and the last medical bills would use up once counted
Threshold: No dollar figure. The entire estate, less liens and encumbrances, must not exceed the homestead allowance, exempt property, family allowance, costs and expenses of administration, reasonable funeral expenses, and reasonable and necessary medical and hospital expenses of the last illness.
Filing Fee: No separate fee. The estate is opened with $215 collected at filing
Timeline: Shorter than an ordinary administration because it skips creditor notice, and the estate can close at any time after distribution. It cannot start until the appointment and inventory are done
Real Estate: Yes
Attorney: No statutory requirement. The comparison against allowances and expenses is where advice pays for itself
Collection of Personal Property by Affidavit
HRS § 560:3-1201, effect at § 560:3-1202
An estate of accounts, belongings and vehicles under the line, where nobody needs to be appointed
Threshold: $100,000 or less, on the GROSS value of the decedent's estate in Hawaii, with nothing subtracted for liens. Hawaii real property counts toward it. Property outside Hawaii does not.
Filing Fee: $0. It is never filed, so no fee attaches. Certified death certificates cost $10 for the first and $4 for each further copy in the same request
Timeline: No statutory waiting period. Usable once a death certificate is in hand
Real Estate: No
Attorney: No
* Hawaii sets probate fees by statute for the whole State, so all four circuits charge the same. HRS § 607-5(b)(14) names $100, paid once for each decedent's estate, for probate, administration, a domiciliary foreign personal representative or ancillary administration, and the schedule folds later matters of the kind listed in items (4) to (9), such as instructions, approval of a sale or compromise and accountings, into that fee. What the clerk collects to open an estate is $215: the $100 probate fee, the $50 administrative fee of § 607-5(c)(32), and the $65 surcharge of § 607-5.7(a)(2). The Judiciary's List of Civil Filing Fees (updated 6/17/2022) prints all three under Probate. Do not quote the $200 civil action fee in § 607-5(b)(1): it belongs to ordinary civil suits, not probate. A jury demand in a probate case is $200 under § 607-5(c)(21).
Unfamiliar terms in the comparison? The Hawaii probate glossary defines them in plain language.
Not sure which type applies to you?
Answer a few questions to see which Hawaii probate path fits this estate.
Take the 2-minute assessment